The sensitivity in some scenes is extraordinary and
surprising. Particularly, when Mohammad finds a fallen chick in a pile of
leaves, was a testament to how acute his sense of hearing is. Until the camera
actually revealed the helpless bird, I was unsure as to what was happening. At
points, Mohammad can be seen moving his fingers through the air and speaking so
quietly he cannot be understood. These moments are a testament to how Mohammad
understands the language of nature, perhaps more than a person with hearing
could.
His father's lack of love is so dissapointing. For such a hard working man, there is a definate conflict between understanding the father's problems and reconciling them with their effect on his own son.
Regarding the ending Stephen Holding in his NYTimes review of the film said that it has a, "wrong-note final image". I'm not too sure of this assessment. I do confess to rolling my eyes a bit at the dramatics of it all because it reminded me of Disney characters being brought back to life by tears or something to that effect. Another criticism might be that the sudden use of computer effects is too big a contrast to the rest of the film, which is more steeped in realism and nature.
Besides that, I found that the final message made sense, as we had been given a taste for the director's beliefs in God with the death of Mohammad's grandmother. Although certainly not as dramatic, she is filled with light and smiles, perhaps because she is greeting God or perhaps, as this image directly follows it, she is thinking of her precious grandson.
Again, I'm ambivalent if it was really 'a wrong-note'. The typical sound-scape of birds and nature is abandoned in the final moments in favor of a sweeping score. In this way, perhaps the filmmakers are ensuring the audience will either be given a positive outlook on the bleak situation or be pushed past the emotional breaking point. My view was entirely positive, although I can't help but wonder if the father's life will either be ruined for good or he'll try to become a better person...
-Claudia
You discuss the criticism of the ending - I agree that if may not be a ‘wrong note’ but, it was somewhat open ended. It is positive and an appropriate ending in that Mohammed’s father finally realizes the love he has for his son. It is open-ended in that we don’t know if this experience will change the way his father lives his life. Will it push him further into misery and self pity for bearing yet again another major loss in his life or will change his outlook and attitude on life? Is the death of his son enough to make him learn to live his life in way closer to the way in which hi son lived? When Mohammed’s hand begins to move and ‘lights up’ I was unsure if this signified Mohammed and his ‘spirit’ finally being liberated by feeling the love of his father which he longed for or was it something of Mohammed being passed to his father.
ReplyDelete